Guess who spent another Friday in another sixth grade class?
The lesson of the day was "The Road Not Taken" by Robert Frost. (Yeah, for sixth graders. Yeah, I know.)
As an introduction, I was to ask them for instances where people had to make difficult choices. I wrote their responses on the board. (I did this three times as the classes swap out, kind of like they'll do in middle school.) I got some standard answers, and I had to give a couple examples to get things going.
The third group, after giving me several pretty standard answers, came up with "leave someone behind in a fire".
Well, that qualifies.
Then we were to discuss if they'd ever faced a choice like this, what choice they made, what effects the other choice might have had, and what advice they'd have for people facing hard choices.
So, I picked a couple choices from the list to discuss, choices like "moving" or "doing your homework". (The second group came up with that one. The class vehemently protested that this was a choice. Having met many kiddos who don't do homework, I assured them that it was, in fact, a choice. We also discussed consequences.)
I couldn't resist. I decided we had to go down the "leave someone behind in a fire" rabbit hole.
They hadn't actually experienced that. (Whew!) But we talked about why someone might be forced to leave someone behind.
Somehow, that turned into them saying if the other person was someone they didn't like, it wouldn't be a hard choice.
I told them that they were wrong. I said that if they were in such a life-and-death situation, if it was them and their worst enemy, they'd save that enemy. They wouldn't leave that person to die in that fire.
They didn't believe me. They said no, they'd have no trouble leaving that person behind.
I'm not so sure. But rather than get into a shouting match, I moved on to the next part of the lesson (reading the poem). It was going long, anyway.
Sometimes I wonder about me, though. I could have picked a way less controversial item from the list they generated to discuss. Ah well.
So, do you think I'm wrong? Would you save a person you disliked from a fire?