Thursday, October 29, 2026

Drawing Inferences

Wednesday. Seventh grade English. 

This was a new-to-me teacher. (She's also new to the school, but she's not new to the district. Last year she was at the continuation high school. I saw some gigs pop up from her, but I always missed them.) The classroom she's in used to belong to an eighth grade history teacher (who retired at the end of the last school year). 

(For fun I went into the archives. I subbed for Mr. C in this room on this day and on this day.)

Ms. V had left very detailed lesson plans. She had written their detailed agenda on the board. What could go wrong? 

Seventh graders. 

They were to read a excerpt from the novel Feed in their textbook, and they had questions to go along with it. This is a very basic, very standard type of assignment for a sub day. It should have been easy. 

But nope. I offered to have us read the story as a class. No, they could read it on their own. But, they were not reading. I pointed out that reading requires them to not be talking, because one can't talk and read at the same time. I mean, I'm way old (compared to them), and I can't do it, so I know they can't do it. 

They did not see my point. They claimed they could read and talk. (If they were reading together, that would have been fine, but that sounds a whole lot different than random conversations that have nothing to do with the assignment.) 

But somehow, they got to the point where they were answering the questions. And I got the same question from several of them. Do we have to draw? 

Draw? I went to investigate. 

The question asked them to "draw an inference" from the text. Two of the characters were having a conversation, but the text explicitly stated that the two characters were not speaking. So, how were they having the conversation? 

The excerpt was from a sci-fi novel where everyone is implanted with a computer feed. I'm hazy on details as I haven't read the book, but I quickly inferred that they were using this computer feed to telepathically (or something) communicate, maybe like texting. 

The problem? They had no idea what "infer" meant. (Although, from the context of the question, it should have been clear they were writing an answer, not drawing a picture.) 

After explaining this three times, it was time to explain it to the whole class, as there comes a point when it's clear that most of the class will have the same question, and repeating the answer for each and every student gets tedious quickly. 

Were they able to infer? Well, kind of. When I explained that they had to figure it out even though it wasn't stated in the text, they got that. But, they were also seventh graders with a sub. They weren't working as diligently as they might with their teacher. 

Although, when I left my note about how many of them weren't making very good use of their time, Ms. V emailed back that she had similar problems with them not doing their work. 

I was very much not surprised at that. I could infer from their behavior that they were not in the habit of taking their schoolwork seriously. Seventh graders. Some of them will learn the hard way that they should really take their schoolwork seriously. 

16 comments:

  1. Well one thing they did learn, the definition of infer!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also echo. I guess that's a win-maybe? Those students were missing an excellent book. I've read Feed twice. In my humble opinion as a reader of both SF and dystopian literature, I would give it five out of five stars. We may be closer to aspects of it than we think. Those students should be paying attention.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's good to know. It was just part of chapter 4 (I think) that we read. Just a taste, really. I like the newer textbooks. They read some interesting things.

      Delete
  3. Sounds like a book I should read. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  4. That sounds like a valuable, creative lesson. Too bad they weren’t taking it more seriously!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anita Joy writing...7th grade - I'm guessing that's about 13? Yep, agree, they need about 3 or 4 years before they might start to see the point.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 12. Turning 13. The 7th graders are very distracted this year. (I've had a 7th grade week.)

      Delete
  6. It makes me fear for the species Ruby Rose

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, this was the age. They actually do grow up.

      Delete
  7. Do we have to draw is such a good misreading, I can picture the whole class asking it one by one. And I like your argument that even you can’t read and talk at the same time, so they can’t either. Hard to argue with that, though I’m sure they tried.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh yes, they claim they can multitask and they're very good at it. One of these days I'll pull out the Dunning-Kruger argument, but that will go above their heads.

      Delete
  8. I infer that you were frustrated

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. With them not doing their work, yeah. With them not knowing what infer means? Nah, I can see how that would happen.

      Delete

I appreciate your comments.

I respond to comments* via email, unless your profile email is not enabled. Then, I'll reply in the comment thread. Eventually. Probably.

*Exception: I do not respond to "what if?" comments, but I do read them all. Those questions are open to your interpretation, and I don't wish to limit your imagination by what I thought the question was supposed to be.